4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag

4.6 5 0 68 68 Fannie May’s classic Buckeye combines creamy, smooth peanut butter and luscious milk chocolate. Individually wrapped.
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Leave a review
Q & A

Reviews

03/04/2023
Homemade feel, store taste
It used to be that you could only find Buckeyes at Farmers Markets or a holiday gift from family but Fannie May allows for the home touch in a mass processing way. Each piece comes individually wrapped which I appreciate for freshness and sanitary travel or sharing. My only criticism is the bottom part of chocolate is a little hard to bite through but overall a delicious choice that I would choose again.
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Delicious
We absolutely loved the product. They we creamy and tasted great
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Delicious!
These were delicious! They were all eaten within a couple days of getting the bag. They weren't made of peanut butter fudge like I was hoping, but I was pleasantly surprised anyway!
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Buckeyes
They we very good my wife liked them very much.I don't eat chocolate a lot but I did like these
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Creamy, classic and delicious!
I received the Fannie May stand up bag of buckeye chocolates to sample in exchange for my honest review. They were very balanced between the chocolate and peanut butter. Very creamy. Delicious. A classic candy! We will definitely buy again and highly recommend!
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Yummy
This is my first time trying buckeye chocolates but surely not my last time they remind me of Reese’s but a bit better the peanut butter middle is rich and creamy
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Awesome
This brand actually tastes great. Smooth chocolate.
  • Home Tested with free product
03/04/2023
Delicious treat
These were the perfect snack. My family ate these within 2 days. Delicious and the perfect size for a light snack. Perfect combo for sweet and rich, very delicious and highly recommended.
  • Home Tested with free product
02/04/2023
New Buckeye favorite.
Each piece is perfect size and individually wrapped so you can share or keep them all to yourself. Creamy peanut butter melts perfectly with the velvety chocolate. Absolute must buy
  • Home Tested with free product
01/04/2023
Good for a package
These are really tasty. The chocolate and peanut butter is sweet and silky smooth. The standup package and individual wrapping is very convenient. There’s nothing that will beat an original buckeye, but this is a close second!
  • Home Tested with free product
01/04/2023
Delicious
I love peanut and chocolate together and Fannie May Buckeye's are the perfect combination. The peanut butter filling is smooth and creamy and tastes delicious. The milk chocolate also has a nice taste. The buckeyes are individually wrapped which is nice. The quality of these chocolates are great. I thoroughly enjoy them!
  • Home Tested with free product
31/03/2023
So yummy!
Fannie May Buckeyes are totally delicious. Smooth milk chocolate wrapped around a peanut butter center. I love the fact they come individually wrapped. They aren’t over sweet like some candies. A great small treat, when you crave something delicious.
  • Home Tested with free product
31/03/2023
Pretty Good
First off, my kids loved these buckeyes. They have a nice ratio of chocolate and peanut butter. I thought they were decent but the taste of the chocolate seemed to be the weak point.
  • Home Tested with free product
31/03/2023
Delicious!
Absolutely delicious! So good and love they are individually wrapped!
  • Home Tested with free product
31/03/2023
Buckeyes Fannymea
Fancy looking packaging. They are individually wrapped which is very convenient to throw in lunches or keep a couple in your purse. They remind me of homemade ones upon opening the package. The taste is a definite winner perfect ratio of chocolates to peanut butter. My entire family liked them. Even the kids and they are very picky about there candies. I will be buying these now. Love the bitsize and individual packs for lunchs. Thanks Fannie Mea
  • Home Tested with free product

Testers' gallery

View More

Q & A

Have a question about this product? Ask or answer below, and help each other buy better.

Loading...

Similar products

4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Lindor Assorted Platinum Truffles Bag
4.9 5 858

4.9 from 858 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Ghirardelli Chocolate Limited Edition Peppermint Bark Assorted Squares and Snowmen Holiday Bag
4.8 5 857

4.8 from 857 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M'S Fudge Brownie Sharing Size Chocolate Candies
4.4 5 1018

4.4 from 1,018 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Reese's PB Cup Dark Chocolate Thins Pouch - 7.37oz
4.6 5 412

4.6 from 412 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Ghirardelli S'more 4 Mug Gift Set
4.7 5 64

4.7 from 64 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Sugar Cookie Kisses Filled Cane 2.56oz
4.6 5 212

4.6 from 212 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Sugar Cookie Kisses 9 Oz.
4.6 5 336

4.6 from 336 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Kathy Kaye's Halloween Popcorn Balls
4.3 5 70

4.3 from 70 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Santa’s Super Sack 38 oz
4.6 5 25

4.6 from 25 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Dove Promises Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel
4.9 5 130

4.9 from 130 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Mars Variety Gusset
4.9 5 94

4.9 from 94 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M’s Snickers Twix & Milky Way Fun Size and Minis Christmas Candy Assortment
4.9 5 89

4.9 from 89 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Skittles Holiday Fruity Candy Jar 14 Oz
4.7 5 85

4.7 from 85 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M’s Milk Chocolate Christmas Candy Gift Jar 13 Oz
4.8 5 110

4.8 from 110 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Dove Promises Holiday Gifts Dark Chocolate Christmas Candy 8.87 Oz
4.8 5 144

4.8 from 144 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >