4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag

4.6 5 0 68 68 Fannie May’s classic Buckeye combines creamy, smooth peanut butter and luscious milk chocolate. Individually wrapped.
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Leave a review
Q & A

Reviews

14/05/2023
Natural Tasty Treat
Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag has a very refreshing natural peanut butter chocolate taste, smooth creamy texture and I really like that they're individually wrap. The stand-up bag is made for convenient access. Great natural tasty treats to sooth that sweet tooth!
  • Home Tested with free product
12/04/2023
Pretty Good!
These are super flavorful and creamy. Not as good as homemade buckeyes, and of course I'm biased because I live in Ohio. Still a yummy treat!
  • Home Tested with free product
07/04/2023
Candy
The best peanut butter buckeye candy ever it just melts in your mouth and rich creamy peanut butter is smooth and I don't think it needs any. Improvements except to have more in the bag
  • Home Tested with free product
07/04/2023
Creamy and delicious
I really enjoyed the Fannie May Buckeyes, they were creamy and delicious. Perfect for a satisfying sweet tooth moment. Packaged individually, and easy to open.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Sweet treat
Tried Fannie mat peanut butter buckeyes. There were each individually wrapped, making it easy to take one as a treat or pack in your lunch box. Great flavor mix of peanut buttter and chocolate with a smooth finish and taste. just the right size.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Delicious
These were so yummy! The peanut butter inside is so thick and creamy and the outside chocolate shell is so good! I sat here and ate half the bag by myself because they were so good.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Lacking Peanut Butter Flavor
These left me wanting much more peanut butter. Buckeyes are usually soft and these are not and just felt like an okay representation of this treat.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Fannie May
I believe these were the best store bought buckeyes I have tasted. I have tried many and they taste more like the homemade ones. At this time i do not believe that any improvements are needed.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Delish and perfect size
I absolutely loved these Fannie May Buckeyes!! The size of these treats were nice size and perfect to a little treat. Only complaint was the bag was small! But I'm sure I was given a sample bag, but I will look for a larger bag so my family can enjoy more. Thanks to Home Tester Panel for allowing me to test and keep this product in exchange for my honest review.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Perfect treat!
I recently had the pleasure of trying Fannie May Chocolate Buckeyes, and I must say, it was absolutely delicious! The combination of rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter was simply heavenly, and I found myself reaching for more and more. The chocolate was smooth and decadent, and the peanut butter filling was perfectly sweet and salty. The two flavors complemented each other perfectly, creating a flavor explosion that left me wanting more. I appreciated that the peanut butter filling wasn't too overpowering, but rather provided just the right amount of sweetness to balance out the richness of the chocolate. The texture of the candy was also great - the outer layer of chocolate had a satisfying crunch while the peanut butter filling was smooth and creamy. It was clear that a lot of care and attention to detail went into making this candy.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
I love sweets
I love these buckeyes!! Fannie May makes delicious chocolate!! I like how each one was individually wrapped.
  • Home Tested with free product
06/04/2023
Love this
These had the perfect creamy peanut butter center. The chocolate was great tasting. I love that the bag is resealable and they are individually wrapped. Be aware you will not eat just one!
  • Home Tested with free product
04/04/2023
Tasty lil treat
Fannie Mae is almost always going to be a safe bet for a quality, tasty treat, the buckeyes are no exception. Once they hit my house they lasted about roughly 40 minutes. Small treats, big mouths, let’s just say they were doomed once they entered the door.
  • Home Tested with free product
04/04/2023
Delicious!
These might be my new favorite treat! They are so delicious! If you love chocolate and peanut butter, this is a perfect mix of the two. I could never have just one. I love that they came in individual wrappers so they weren’t all stuck together. Yummy!!
  • Home Tested with free product
04/04/2023
Delicious!
I absolutely loved this bag of Fannie May buckeyes! There was just enough chocolate and peanut butter to make it a perfect snack!
  • Home Tested with free product

Testers' gallery

View More

Q & A

Have a question about this product? Ask or answer below, and help each other buy better.

Loading...

Similar products

4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Lindor Assorted Platinum Truffles Bag
4.9 5 851

4.9 from 851 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Ghirardelli Chocolate Limited Edition Peppermint Bark Assorted Squares and Snowmen Holiday Bag
4.8 5 856

4.8 from 856 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M'S Fudge Brownie Sharing Size Chocolate Candies
4.4 5 1017

4.4 from 1,017 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Reese's PB Cup Dark Chocolate Thins Pouch - 7.37oz
4.6 5 411

4.6 from 411 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Ghirardelli S'more 4 Mug Gift Set
4.7 5 64

4.7 from 64 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Sugar Cookie Kisses Filled Cane 2.56oz
4.6 5 212

4.6 from 212 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Sugar Cookie Kisses 9 Oz.
4.6 5 336

4.6 from 336 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Kathy Kaye's Halloween Popcorn Balls
4.3 5 70

4.3 from 70 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Santa’s Super Sack 38 oz
4.6 5 25

4.6 from 25 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Dove Promises Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel
4.9 5 130

4.9 from 130 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Mars Variety Gusset
4.9 5 94

4.9 from 94 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M’s Snickers Twix & Milky Way Fun Size and Minis Christmas Candy Assortment
4.9 5 89

4.9 from 89 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Skittles Holiday Fruity Candy Jar 14 Oz
4.7 5 85

4.7 from 85 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
M&M’s Milk Chocolate Christmas Candy Gift Jar 13 Oz
4.8 5 110

4.8 from 110 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >
4.5oz Peanut Butter Buckeyes Standup Bag
Dove Promises Holiday Gifts Dark Chocolate Christmas Candy 8.87 Oz
4.8 5 144

4.8 from 144 Reviews

Tried it? Rate It >