The dark chocolate assortment is widely regarded for its delicious and rich taste, high quality, and pleasant texture, frequently described as smooth, creamy, and melting in the mouth. Many customers appreciate the variety of flavors, including specific positive mentions for caramel, lava cake, and pixies. A significant number of reviewers, including those who typically do not prefer dark chocolate, found the assortment enjoyable. The balance of sweetness is often highlighted, though some found the chocolates to be excessively sweet. The combination of salt and chocolate is frequently praised, with a few noting excessive salt content. The product is highly recommended by many customers, with intentions for repurchase or gifting. Fannie May, as a brand, receives largely positive recognition, although some express mixed or negative perceptions. Packaging received both positive comments for aspects like a display card and negative feedback regarding presentation. Additionally, some customers noted concerns about ingredients and certain texture aspects, such as toughness or thick coating, and expressed dislike for specific flavors like Pixies, Brownie Batter Truffles, and Sea Salt Caramels.